Tuesday, September 7, 2021

Jimmy Waghorn Comes on Board: Rating John Rhodes in the early Jimmy Waghorn Era, 1935-1940, plus more Miles Burtons

The year 1935 saw a big change in John Street's "John Rhode" series of detective novels, with a younger, college-educated young cop, Jimmy Waghorn, coming on board to join previous series regular policeman, Inspector/Superintendent Hanslet.  Until the war, when Jimmy goes off into intelligence work and Hanslet delays his retirement, these two will work together at the Yard investigating cases and getting their asses handed to them by testy amateur sleuth Dr. Priestley.  In it you see the beginnings of all the grizzled old superior and posh young upstart pairings you have now seen so many times in crime fiction.  Here's a rating of their books between 1935 and 1940, plus Street's "Miles Burton" detective novels from the same years, featuring insouciant gentleman amatyer sleuth Desmond Merrion and Inspector Arnold.

aka The Bloody Tower

15 JOHN RHODES

1935

The Corpse in the Car (this is the last book without Jimmy Waghorn) *****

Hendon's First Case ****

Mystery at Olympia ****

1936

Death at Breakfast ***

In Face of the Verdict ***

1937

Death in the Hopfields ****

Death on the Board *****

Proceed with Caution ****

1937

Invisible Weapons ****

The Bloody Tower *****

1939

Drop to His Death (nonseries, with John Dickson Carr) ****

Death Pays a Dividend (introduces Jimmy love interest, Diana Morpeth) ****

Death on Sunday ****

1940

Death on the Boat-Train ****

Murder at Lilac Cottage ***


14 MILES BURTONS

1935

The Devereux Court Mystery ****

The Milk Churn Murder ***

1936

Death in the Tunnel ****

Murder of a Chemist ****

Where Is Barbara Prentice? *****

1937

Death at the Club ****

Murder in Crown Passage ***

1938

Death at Low Tide ****

The Platinum Cat *****

1939

Death Leaves No Card (Arnold only) ****

Mr. Babbacombe Dies ***

Murder in the Coalhole ***

1940

Mr. Westerby Missing ****

Death Takes a Flat ***1/2


RHODES

3 5-star

9 4-star

3 3-star

BURTONS

2 5-star

7 4-star

1 3.5-star

4 3-star

No comments:

Post a Comment