I was looking back at some Leo Bruce mysteries the last few weeks, preparatory to selling off a number of my books, including some of the rare Bruces. Two of the rarest Bruces are two titles from the mid- to late Sixties, Death on the Black Sands and Death on Romney Marsh. Academy Chicago, which began reprinting Leo Bruce mysteries in paperback not long after the author's death in 1979, for some reason has declined to reprint these two titles for over four decades now. I have a theory as to why in the case of one, but not so much in the case of the other. Not a single copy of these two titles is available for sale, but happily for me I tracked both of them down many years ago so am able to review them here. I will probably be putting them up for sale soon.
Death on the Black Sands, published in 1966, was the 15th of Leo Bruce's 23 Carolus Deene detective novels, detailing the investigations of the intrepid and inquisitive schoolmaster detective. It takes place not in England but in an imaginary town on Spain's Costa del Sol near the British territory of Gibraltar. Two years earlier crime writers John and Emery Bonett had started a series of mysteries set on the Costa Brava in northeastern Spain; and perhaps this inspired Bruce two years later to set a Carolus Deene mystery on the Spanish coast as well.
![]() |
| the man on the cover resembles the author |
At the time of his writing Black Sands, Bruce--aka mainstream English writer Rupert Croft-Cooke--was still living in Tangier, Morocco, where he had moved with his Indian secretary-companion Joseph Susei Mari in 1954 after his release from a term in prison for "homosexual offences." He no longer felt that England was a safe place for a gay man. Three years later the government's Wolfenden Committee issued a report recommending the decriminalization of homosexuality between consenting adults, a stance which Parliament did not adopt until a decade later with the passage of the Sexual Offences Act of 1967. The next year Bruce, now 65, along with faithful Joseph left Tangier for England, finally reaching their destination in 1973. Bruce seemed in no great hurry to return to England, calling this his long journey home. He and Joseph made lots of detours around continental Europe.
Bruce doubtlessly was familiar with the Costa del Sol, which he dismissed as no different from an English seaside resort, being crowded with Englishmen and woman and nary a genuine Spaniard. And his mood in the book can be described as rather sour. I think here I'll quote in full from a short review of the novel which I posted in 2007 at the old Golden Age Detection page at Yahoo groups, now found at the GAdetection wiki:
With this elusive title I've now read every Leo Bruce detective novel bar the early Case with Four Clowns. The book deals with murder among an expatriate community in coastal Spain near Gibraltar. Perpetual schoolboy Rupert Priggley, again abandoned by his much-married, much-divorced socialite parents, is temporarily abandoned there and calls in his schoolmaster with the revoltingly large private income and an amateur detective, Carolus Deene. The expats are a Ngaio Marsh-esque group of grotesque, unsympathetic nymphos and dipsos, as the odiously precocious young Rupert says, giving Bruce ample room for satire.
Although we are away from the familiar environs of Queen's School, Newminster, Deene thoughtfully brings his housekeeper and cook, Mrs. Stick, and her husband, simply Stick, along, so we get some amusing moments as the insular Mrs. Stick copes with Spanish ways and cooking. Pompous Queen's School headmaster Mr. Gorringer and his wife also coincidentally decide to vary their summer vacation routine this year, changing their destination from Bruges, Belgium to, yes, southern Spain, so we get Gorringer at Deene's final exposition, as per tradition.
"Croft-Cooke's experiences abroad are not reflected in his mystery novels," declares the Dictionary of Literary Biography, but clearly Black Sands reflects something of Croft-Cooke's life in Tangier from the mid-Fifties to the late Sixties. The author had become tired of life among the decadent "exiles" by this time, a mood clearly reflected in the Carolus Deene novel. He would leave Tangier two years later.
Not one of the very best Deenes but in the top half, I would say. As with many of Bruce's murders, things are cleverly turned around on the reader, with a satisfying twist at the end. The author also takes time to plant Actual Clues (!) that allow for the process of Ratiocination to take place. Bruce to my mind is often one of the more adept clue smiths--the clues are there, but not too obvious.
I think all that still stands on a reread. Let me go into a little more detail here though. Unusually for Bruce the characters in the tale, which centers on the murder of local big-spending playboy Davy Devigne, include two queer couples, pansyish Hilary and his strong, silent working class boytoy Tommy, a former milkman, and braying, bull dykeish Georgie and demure lipstick lesbianish Sweetie. I hope I am not offending anyone with this language, which is very much of the time of the novel. "Groundbreaking" films like The Killing of Sister George (1968) (lesbian) and The Gay Deceivers (1969) (gay, duh) soon followed Black Sands; and though fascinating works their depictions of homosexuality I would argue is ultimately negative, exploitative and spiritually diminishing. The stage version of Sister George upon which the film was based appeared in 1964, and I suspect that Leo Bruce was familiar with it.
Georgie and Sweetie, a domineering Butch and submissive femme, resemble Georgie and Childie from Sister George, not to mention the tone of Elton John's 1973 catchy song "All the Young Girls Love Alice." Although to be fair Michael Greer's flaming queen in Gay Deceivers has enjoyed a second life in social media for a forty-second scene in which he hysterically screeches at a woman the immortal line, "You dirty bitch! Look what you've done to my peonies!" A lot of young gays, not having lived through the years when these were the only representations of gay men in media, find this rather amusing. In isolation I find it rather amusing myself. (I love Michael Greer.)
Despite Bruce's absurd six-month incarceration for "homosexual offences" (he was accused of sexually assaulting two strapping young English sailors, who were coerced into making this accusation), he never wanted to be known as a gay writer. He never wrote gay fiction, although around the time of Black Sands he did publish a biography of Oscar Wilde, which is pretty critical of his flamboyance and prideful self-destructiveness. Bruce was of a generation of gay men instinctively circumspect about his sexuality (understandably). In the whole range of his Carolus Deene detective fiction I remember, all from the Sixties, one trans character and a hotel bellboy who thinks (wrongly) that Carolus is trying to pick him up (which he is perfectly open to) and then these two very stereotypical queer characters in Black Sands.
In this novel there is also a Lolly Mellon (both nympho and dipso, to quote Rupert) who drunkenly chases after anything in pants as they used to say, but is especially interested in Tommy, leading to many queeny displays of jealousy from Hilary. Again it's moderately amusing but a bit dispiriting to someone like me, who has written quite a bit about queer stereotyping in crime fiction. We were a few years off from the time when gays and lesbians could be portrayed as "just like the straights," perhaps even essentially boring and unmemorable people, rather than exotic, neurotic fags and dykes.
Leo Bruce was in a relationship with Joseph for some 35 years, until the author's death in 1979; they were essentially a gay couple, married in all but name. It would have been nice if a writer of Bruce's talent had been able to being himself to write non-stereotypically and positively about a gay couple, but such was not to be. Perhaps his publisher would have been mystified by such a portrayal. Happy, non-neurotic gays?!! How is that possible?
Personally I'd have loved to see Carolus run off with Rupert Priggley, who started off when the series began in 1955 as an elder precociously experienced, Noel Cowardish schoolboy and is still there in the series as late as 1966 and 1967, by which time he should have been pushing 30. Honestly, they act like a couple and Carolus never in the series shows remotely credible inclinations toward heterosexuality. Improbably he's a throwback to the sexless amateur detective: "Mr. Deene, what is you sex life, if any?"
![]() |
| Joseph (with drink) and Rupert (at bar) |
I suspect that the negative queer stereotypes in Black Sands explain why the novel has never been reprinted, in contrast with so many other Leo Bruce books. But, the truth is, it's an enjoyable book and I don't doubt that Bruce aficionados would enjoy it. It doesn't have a line as memorable as "You dirty bitch! Look what you've done to my peonies!" but I was much amused by Mrs. Stick repeatedly referring to her sweet young Spanish helper as "Carmelita, as she calls herself," as if she finds it offensive that the Spanish girl has a Spanish name, rather than something sensibly English like Gwendolyn, Gertrude or Esmeralda.
Mrs. Stick is as always a delightful Dickensian creation, satirized with an affection which Bruce in his fiction never afforded his own kind, even though in the same novel he takes some potshots at Field Marshall Montgomery who, though believed by some to have been a repressed homosexual, as a member of the House of Lords in 1967 vehemently opposed passage of the Sexual Offences Act, calling it a "charter for buggery" and declaring: "I know it is said that this is allowed in France and some other countries. We are not French, we are not from other nations, we are British--thank God."
Rupert Croft-Cooke never had that sort of English insularity, thank God, but I think he did have sensitivity about his homosexuality (he never wanted to be thought of as effeminate, for example), and I think that sensitivity prevented Death on the Black Sands from being less dated than it is in terms of its depiction of queer characters. This was a few years before PRIDE, and that shows.



No comments:
Post a Comment